Email Marketing

Check Your Sender Reputation - Then Learn How to Improve

Hero Image
Much like a credit score, your sender reputation is a key factor in determining whether your email messages will get delivered to the inbox. Each sender has a reputation score that mailbox providers use — along with other information — to determine whether to allow your email into their inboxes.
Many mailbox providers, such as Gmail or Microsoft, use your sender reputation as a first layer of filtering that determines if your email is rejected or delivered. Even when delivered, it’s important to find out whether your campaign is going to the inbox or spam folder. These gatekeepers each utilize a different algorithm, which can affect your campaign based on a number of different signals indicating your trustworthiness as a sender. Due to this, your emails may be landing successfully in Gmail inboxes — but heading straight to the spam folder for Outlook recipients. Similarly, some inboxes rely on their IP reputation instead of domain reputation to access inbox vs. spam placement.
Hidden Anchor

Domain reputation vs. IP reputation

IP reputation is when your reputation score is determined by your IP address. Every email message is sent from a specific computer or server that has an identifying address. This is the IP address, through which mailbox providers recognize and judge your emails.

However, IP reputation is also impacted by if you’re using a new IP address and/or a shared IP. If you have a new IP address, your reputation is scrutinized because you don’t have an established sending history. Meanwhile, through a shared IP, your reputation is affected by the actions of all other senders that use the same IP. If they make poor sending decisions, some mailbox providers may decide to block you along with them.

Domain reputation is when your reputation score is also factored on the domain level, independently from your IP address. Your domain reputation is associated with the specific and separate domains, instead of individual IPs, from which you send emails. Senders with a good IP reputation but a bad domain reputation will still have difficulty getting into subscribers’ inboxes. Although they are independent reputation signals, mailbox providers usually consider both when determining what emails will land in inboxes.

“We were struggling with inbox placement with certain mailbox providers and our emails being sent to spam. Prior to this campaign, we worked to improve our sender reputation. By the time we were ready to launch the campaign, we finally felt confident enough to send it to our full subscriber list.”

– Katherine Pachowicz, marketing specialist, CampSaver, on how Validity made their holiday campaign a success.

Hidden Anchor

Does sender reputation affect email deliverability?

Your sender reputation is one of the main factors that mailbox providers consider to determine your email deliverability — meaning where your email goes. This will help determine whether it goes into the main inbox, straight to the spam folder or blocked. To ensure great email deliverability, you need a good sender reputation.

To improve inbox placement for your email messages, check your domain reputations and IP reputations regularly and address any factors that may put your reputation at risk.

For more tips, here’s a deeper dive into sender reputation.

Hidden Anchor

How to check sender reputation

Mailbox providers track the domains and IPs associated with your email messages and, subsequently, how subscribers have engaged with your messages to determine your sender reputation. Each mailbox provider then uses its unique algorithm to give your domain and IPs a reputation score. This score will significantly impact whether your messages get delivered to the inbox, the spam folder, or are blocked by the mailbox provider.

So how do you check your domain reputation to better understand how mailbox providers view you as a sender? Senders can use Gmail Postmaster and Microsoft SNDS to check their reputations.

You are also able to check your IP reputation scores through Sender Score, a service provided by Validity.

Do you know your Sender Score?
Check it for free.

Hidden Anchor

How to improve your domain reputation

Since each mailbox provider has its own complex methods to determine your sender reputation, it can be difficult to analyze exactly how to improve your reputation. Providers continually evaluate and update unique algorithms and scores to prevent spammers and bad senders from beating the system to reach inboxes. However, there are steps you can take toward establishing a good reputation.

Does your sender reputation need a tune-up? Try this 5-point inspection to keep your email program in gear.

Hidden Anchor

Below is a list of best practices to follow to improve your domain reputation: 

Hidden Anchor

Analyze your bounces

When going through campaign reports, senders should analyze their bounce rates since they can provide direct clues as to why your emails aren’t being delivered. If you spot any inconsistencies or patterns, they may help you determine the reasons for your rejection — whether it’s due to content with spam-like characteristics or your IP/domain reputation score.

Bounces act as red flags and can harm your reputation score, so it’s important to lower them as much as possible.

Hidden Anchor

Check feedback loops

Feedback loops (FBLs) allow mailbox providers to view when recipients have “complained” about their messages, specifically if subscribers have marked your messages as spam or blocked you. The higher your complaint rate, the more likely a mailbox provider will block your messages or deliver them to the spam folder. By checking your FBLs, you can analyze which messages are receiving complaints and strategize how to fix the problem.

Hidden Anchor

Regularly monitor and cleanse your email list

As your mailing list grows, it’s inevitable that mistyped or invalid email addresses will begin to pop up. However, those bad addresses can directly damage your reputation score and prevent you from focusing your attention on legitimate subscribers. Actively monitor your email marketing lists to remove invalid or inactive email addresses, so you reduce the risk of not reaching your real audience.

Learn more about how Validity BriteVerify can help you clean your email lists.

Hidden Anchor

Make sure your email content is relevant

Create and design email content that is timely, value-added and personalized for your subscribers. The more relevant your content is, the less likely subscribers will “complain” about your emails to their mailbox providers. Additionally, subscribers will be more likely to positively interact with your emails, which will have a positive impact on your reputation score.
Hidden Anchor

Establish a separate subdomain for key message streams

A subdomain is an additional part of your main, or root, domain. This subcategory is in your main domain and allows you to use a different IP address to send specific emails, while still staying on the same root domain. For example, the root domain validity.com could have several subdomains, such as mail.validity.com or store.validity.com. This helps ensure your emails are not directly affected by the reputation of other types of emails.

It’s also best practice to send transactional emails, such as subscriber account activity or purchase confirmations, from a specific subdomain. By keeping transactional messages in a separate subdomain, you can help ensure the reputation of your marketing messages does not negatively impact the inbox placement for these critical messages.

Hidden Anchor

Optimize your contact strategy

To increase your email engagement, avoid overwhelming your audience with too many emails. Segment your email list based on engagement data to determine the right frequency for highly engaged vs less engaged subscribers. Establish a contact strategy based on optimal frequency and personalized, value-added content to avoid messages being marked as spam.

With Validity, businesses both small and large can use our diverse array of services to monitor and improve their domain reputations. Everest, our comprehensive email success platform, will give you crucial, real-time insights and deliverability guidance to help you to improve your domain reputation. We also offer Sender Certification, which is the only sending practices program that helps senders maintain high inbox placement rates with top mailbox providers. Meanwhile, our BriteVerify product can reduce your bounce rate by verifying that your list only includes legitimate subscribers.

Schedule a free demonstration to see how Validity can improve your sender reputation so you get more messages to more people.

Products

BriteVerify

BriteVerify email verification ensures that an email address actually exists in real-time

DemandTools

The #1 global data quality tool used by thousands of Salesforce admins

Everest

Insights and deliverability guidance from the only all-in-one email marketing solution

GridBuddy Cloud

Transform how you interact with your data through the versatility of grids.

Return Path

World-class deliverability applications to optimize email marketing programs

Trust Assessments

A revolutionary new solution for assessing Salesforce data quality

Solutions

Validity for Email

Increase inbox placement and maximize subscriber reach with clean and actionable data

Validity for Data Management

Simplify data management with solutions that improve data quality and increase CRM adoption

Validity for Sales Productivity

Give your sales team back hours per day with tools designed to increase productivity and mitigate pipeline risks in real-time